книги / 771
.pdfGermany 2020
Energy Policy Review
Germany 2020
Energy Policy Review
INTERNATIONAL ENERGY AGENCY
The IEA examines |
IEA member |
IEA association |
the full spectrum |
countries: |
countries: |
of energy issues |
|
|
including oil, gas |
Australia |
Brazil |
and coal supply and |
Austria |
China |
demand, renewable |
Belgium |
India |
energy technologies, |
Canada |
Indonesia |
electricity markets, |
Czech Republic |
Morocco |
energy efficiency, |
Denmark |
Singapore |
access to energy, |
Estonia |
South Africa |
demand side |
Finland |
Thailand |
management and |
France |
|
much more. Through |
Germany |
|
its work, the IEA |
Greece |
|
advocates policies |
Hungary |
|
that will enhance |
Ireland |
|
the reliability, |
Italy |
|
affordability and |
Japan |
|
sustainability of |
Korea |
|
energy in its 30 |
Luxembourg |
|
member countries, |
Mexico |
|
8 association |
Netherlands |
|
countries and |
New Zealand |
|
beyond. |
Norway |
|
|
Poland |
|
|
Portugal |
|
|
Slovak Republic |
|
|
Spain |
|
|
Sweden |
|
|
Switzerland |
|
|
Turkey |
|
|
United Kingdom |
|
|
United States |
|
|
The European |
|
|
Commission also |
|
|
participates in the |
|
|
work of the IEA |
|
Please note that this publication is subject to specific restrictions that limit its use and distribution. The terms and conditions are available online at www.iea.org/t&c/
Source: IEA. All rights reserved.
International Energy Agency Website: www.iea.org
Foreword
The International Energy Agency (IEA) has conducted in-depth peer reviews of its member countries’ energy policies since 1976. This process not only supports energy policy development, but also encourages the exchange of and learning from international best practices and experiences. In short, by seeing what has worked – or not – in the “real world”, these reviews help to identify policies that achieve their objectives and bring concrete results. Recently, the IEA has moved to modernise the reviews by focusing on some of the key energy challenges in today’s rapidly changing energy markets.
Germany is an important and active member of the IEA. I am grateful to Peter Altmaier, Federal Minister for Economic Affairs and Energy, for his collaborative spirit and commitment to building a secure and sustainable energy future. Together, we coorganised the first Global Ministerial Conference on System Integration of Renewables in Berlin in October 2019. The event brought together government ministers, industry chief executives and other high-ranking officials from around the world to share best practices and innovative ideas to help fully grasp the opportunities of wind and solar energy.
Since the IEA review of German energy policies in 2013, the Energiewende has remained the defining feature of the country’s energy landscape. In place for nearly a decade, the Energiewende is a major plan for transforming the German energy system, making it more efficient and supplied mainly by renewable energy sources. It aims to phase out electricity generation from nuclear power by the end of 2022.
To date, the Energiewende is clearly visible in electricity generation, where it has been effective at increasing the share of renewable energy supply. Still, despite progress on lowering overall emissions, Germany is struggling to meet its near-term targets. This is in large part because of uneven progress across sectors, with notable challenges in transport and heating. Now, the government must refocus its efforts to achieve stronger emissions reductions in these other sectors. The IEA welcomes the recently adopted climate action plan, which includes a carbon price in the transport and heating sectors, as an important step in the right direction.
Energy security remains a focus area for the IEA, and I am pleased to observe that Germany has maintained a high degree of oil, natural gas and electricity supply security. As the nuclear and coal phase-outs increase Germany’s reliance on natural gas, it will be increasingly important for the country to continue efforts to diversify its gas supply options, including through the import of liquefied natural gas.
I strongly believe that both policy and regulatory reforms can move Germany towards a cost-efficient, equitable and sustainable path to meeting its highly ambitious energy transition goals. It is my hope that this report will help Germany as it undertakes this crucial endeavor.
Dr Fatih Birol
Executive Director
International Energy Agency
3
FOREWORD
ENERGY INSIGHTS
1. Executive summary..................................................................................................... |
11 |
Overview............................................................................................................................ |
11 |
Emissions targets .............................................................................................................. |
11 |
Electricity transition............................................................................................................ |
12 |
Beyond electricity .............................................................................................................. |
14 |
Energy security.................................................................................................................. |
15 |
Key recommendations:...................................................................................................... |
15 |
2. General energy policy................................................................................................. |
17 |
Country overview............................................................................................................... |
17 |
Supply and demand........................................................................................................... |
19 |
Institutions.......................................................................................................................... |
24 |
Energiewende.................................................................................................................... |
26 |
Pricing and taxation........................................................................................................... |
31 |
Assessment ....................................................................................................................... |
32 |
Recommendations............................................................................................................. |
35 |
ENERGY SYSTEM TRANSFORMATION
3. Energy and climate change........................................................................................ |
37 |
||
Overview............................................................................................................................ |
37 |
||
Energy-related CO2 emissions .......................................................................................... |
38 |
||
CO2 drivers and carbon intensity....................................................................................... |
40 |
||
Institutions.......................................................................................................................... |
41 |
||
Emissions reduction targets and policies.......................................................................... |
42 |
||
Focus area: Decarbonising heat and sector coupling |
.......................................................50 |
||
Adapting to climate change ............................................................................................... |
56 |
||
Assessment ....................................................................................................................... |
57 |
||
Recommendations............................................................................................................. |
59 |
||
4. Energy efficiency......................................................................................................... |
63 |
||
|
|
|
|
5 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS |
|
Overview............................................................................................................................ |
63 |
Energy consumption by sector.......................................................................................... |
65 |
Institutions.......................................................................................................................... |
69 |
Energy efficiency policy..................................................................................................... |
69 |
Assessment ....................................................................................................................... |
77 |
Recommendations............................................................................................................. |
80 |
5. Renewable energy....................................................................................................... |
80 |
Overview............................................................................................................................ |
83 |
Supply and demand........................................................................................................... |
84 |
Institutions.......................................................................................................................... |
88 |
Policies and measures ...................................................................................................... |
89 |
Assessment .................................................................................................................... |
106 |
Recommendations.......................................................................................................... |
109 |
6. Energy technology research, development and demonstration......................... |
113 |
Overview......................................................................................................................... |
113 |
Public spending on energy RD&D.................................................................................. |
113 |
7th Energy Research Programme................................................................................... |
115 |
International collaborations ............................................................................................ |
118 |
Assessment .................................................................................................................... |
119 |
Recommendations.......................................................................................................... |
121 |
ENERGY SECURITY |
|
7. Electricity................................................................................................................... |
123 |
Overview......................................................................................................................... |
123 |
Electricity supply............................................................................................................. |
124 |
Electricity market structure and regulation..................................................................... |
127 |
Assessment .................................................................................................................... |
141 |
Recommendations.......................................................................................................... |
144 |
8. Natural gas ................................................................................................................ |
147 |
Overview......................................................................................................................... |
147 |
6
|
TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Supply and demand........................................................................................................ |
148 |
Institutions....................................................................................................................... |
150 |
Upstream policy.............................................................................................................. |
151 |
Market structure.............................................................................................................. |
151 |
Infrastructure................................................................................................................... |
153 |
Alternative applications for gas ...................................................................................... |
155 |
Energy security............................................................................................................... |
157 |
Assessment .................................................................................................................... |
160 |
Recommendations.......................................................................................................... |
162 |
9. Coal ............................................................................................................................ |
165 |
Overview......................................................................................................................... |
165 |
Supply and demand........................................................................................................ |
166 |
Coal mining policy .......................................................................................................... |
167 |
EU emissions limits ........................................................................................................ |
169 |
Coal phase-out ............................................................................................................... |
169 |
Lignite power reserve ..................................................................................................... |
171 |
R&D and technology development................................................................................. |
171 |
Assessment .................................................................................................................... |
171 |
Recommendations.......................................................................................................... |
173 |
10. Oil ............................................................................................................................. |
175 |
Overview......................................................................................................................... |
175 |
Supply and demand........................................................................................................ |
176 |
Trade .............................................................................................................................. |
178 |
Germany’s oil supply and demand outlook .................................................................... |
180 |
Oil industry structure....................................................................................................... |
180 |
Prices and taxation ......................................................................................................... |
181 |
Oil market and policies ................................................................................................... |
183 |
Oil supply infrastructure.................................................................................................. |
186 |
Oil emergency policies and organisation ....................................................................... |
189 |
Assessment .................................................................................................................... |
192 |
|
7 |
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS |
|
|
Recommendations.......................................................................................................... |
193 |
|
11. Nuclear..................................................................................................................... |
195 |
|
Overview......................................................................................................................... |
195 |
|
Industry structure............................................................................................................ |
196 |
|
Nuclear phase-out .......................................................................................................... |
198 |
|
Institutions....................................................................................................................... |
199 |
|
Nuclear waste management........................................................................................... |
202 |
|
Decommissioning ........................................................................................................... |
205 |
|
Nuclear research and competencies.............................................................................. |
208 |
|
Assessment .................................................................................................................... |
209 |
|
Recommendations.......................................................................................................... |
211 |
|
ANNEXES |
|
|
ANNEX A: Organisations visited .................................................................................... |
213 |
|
ANNEX B: Energy balances and key statistical data..................................................... |
215 |
|
ANNEX C: International Energy Agency “Shared Goals” .............................................. |
219 |
|
ANNEX D: Glossary and list of abbreviations ................................................................ |
221 |
|
LIST OF FIGURES, TABLES AND BOXES |
|
|
Figures |
|
|
2.1 |
Map of Germany ...................................................................................................... |
18 |
2.2 |
Overview of the German energy system by fuel and sector, 2018 ......................... |
20 |
2.3 |
TPES by source, 1973-2018 ................................................................................... |
21 |
2.4 |
Breakdown of TPES in IEA member countries, 2018 ............................................. |
21 |
2.5 |
Energy production by source, 1998-2018 ............................................................... |
22 |
2.6 |
Self-sufficiency (production/TPES) by energy source, 1998-2018 ......................... |
22 |
2.7 |
TFC by sector, 1997-2017....................................................................................... |
23 |
2.8 |
TFC by source and sector, 2017 ............................................................................. |
24 |
2.9 |
Structure and targets of the Energy Concept.......................................................... |
27 |
3.1 |
GHG emissions by sector, 1990-2017 .................................................................... |
38 |
3.2 |
Energy-related CO emissions by sector, 1990-2017............................................. |
39 |
3.3 |
Energy-related CO emissions by energy source, 2005-17.................................... |
39 |
3.4 |
Energy-related CO2 emissions and main drivers in Germany, 1990-2017............. |
40 |
3.5 |
CO2 intensity in Germany and selected IEA member countries, 1990-2017.......... |
41 |
3.6CO2 intensity of power and heat generation in Germany and in other selected
IEA member countries, 1990-2017 |
..........................................................................41 |
8
|
TABLE OF CONTENTS |
|
3.7 |
Germany’s energy and climate targets.................................................................... |
42 |
3.8 |
Sectoral targets in the Climate Action Plan 2050.................................................... |
45 |
3.9 |
Energy supply in residential space heating in Germany, 2016............................... |
51 |
3.10 |
District heating sales by fuel used for generation, 2017 ......................................... |
54 |
4.1 |
Energy supply and drivers, 2000-17........................................................................ |
63 |
4.2 |
Energy intensity in IEA member countries, 2017 .................................................... |
64 |
4.3 |
Final energy consumption by sector, 2000-17 ........................................................ |
65 |
4.4 |
TFC in residential and commercial sectors by source, 2000-17............................. |
66 |
4.5 |
Breakdown of TFC in the residential sector, 2017 .................................................. |
66 |
4.6 |
TFC in industry by source, 2000-17 ........................................................................ |
67 |
4.7 |
Energy consumption in manufacturing industry sectors, 2017 ............................... |
67 |
4.8 |
TFC in transport by source, 2000-17....................................................................... |
68 |
4.9 |
Fuel efficiency (kilometre/litre) in road transport by mode, 2000-16....................... |
69 |
5.1 |
Share of renewable energy in the German energy system, 1978-2018 ................. |
84 |
5.2 |
Renewable energy and waste in TPES, 2000-18 ................................................... |
84 |
5.3 |
Renewable energy and waste in electricity generation, 2000-18 ........................... |
85 |
5.4 |
Biogas consumption by sector, 2005-17 ................................................................. |
86 |
5.5Final energy consumption for heat generation based on renewable energy
sources, 2000-18 |
.....................................................................................................87 |
5.6Final energy consumption for transport based on renewable energy sources,
|
2000-2018................................................................................................................ |
|
|
88 |
5.7 |
Progress towards 2020 targets................................................................................ |
90 |
||
5.8 |
Policy support changes and renewables capacity deployment, 1990-2017 ........... |
92 |
||
5.9 |
Price reductions in recent auctions for solar PV and onshore wind, 2014-19 ........ |
93 |
||
5.10 |
EEG surcharge and average wholesale electricity market price, 2010-18 ............. |
94 |
||
5.11 |
Share of solar and wind in electricity generation in IEA countries, 2018................ |
95 |
||
5.12 |
Conventional electricity generation in Germany, November 2017.......................... |
95 |
||
5.13 |
IEA forecast of renewable capacity additions in Germany, 2018-24 ...................... |
96 |
||
5.14 |
Share of renewable energy sources in heating and cooling, IEA countries, 2017 .98 |
|||
5.15 |
Biomass versus oil heating in new installations in Germany, 2008-18................ |
100 |
||
5.16 |
Fuel shares in district heating in Germany, 2017................................................. |
101 |
||
5.17 |
Fuel shares in sales and energy consumption for residential space |
|
||
|
heating in Germany .............................................................................................. |
102 |
||
5.18 |
Heat oil fuel prices in IEA in Q1 2019................................................................... |
103 |
||
5.19 |
Household delivered heat costs for different heating appliances, 2018 .............. |
103 |
||
5.20 |
Renewable energy in transport by source in selected countries, 2016 ............... |
105 |
||
5.21 |
GHG emissions reductions from biofuels used for CPQ compliance |
|
||
|
2014-17, compared with gasoline and diesel....................................................... |
106 |
||
6.1 |
Government energy RD&D spending per GDP in IEA countries, 2017............... |
114 |
||
6.2 |
Government energy RD&D spending by category, 2010-17................................ |
114 |
||
6.3 |
German research and innovation system stakeholders....................................... |
115 |
||
7.1 |
Electricity generation by source, 2018 ................................................................. |
123 |
||
7.2 |
Electricity generation by source in IEA, 2018....................................................... |
124 |
||
7.3 |
Electricity supply by source, 2000-18................................................................... |
125 |
||
7.4 |
Electricity net imports and exports by country, 2000-17 ...................................... |
125 |
||
7.5 |
Monthly electricity generation by source, July 2016-June 2019 .......................... |
126 |
||
7.6 |
Electricity consumption (TFC) by consuming sector, 2000-17............................. |
127 |
||
7.7 |
Electricity prices in IEA member countries, 2018................................................. |
128 |
||
7.8 |
Electricity prices in Germany and selected IEA countries, 2000-18 .................... |
128 |
||
7.9 |
Average annual power supply disruptions in European countries, 2016............. |
140 |
||
8.1 |
Share of natural gas in the German energy system, 1978-2018 ......................... |
147 |
||
8.2 |
Natural gas supply by source, 2000-18................................................................ |
148 |
||
8.3 |
Germany’s natural gas net imports by country, 2000-18 ..................................... |
149 |
||
|
|
|
|
|
|
9 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
TABLE OF CONTENTS